Understanding SEBI’s Updated Framework for Short Selling6 min read

Understanding SEBI’s Updated Framework for Short Selling6 min read

A Tale of Market Moves

Imagine a seasoned trader, Arjun, who thrives on volatility—finding opportunities when the market rises and falls. But with evolving regulations, staying ahead means understanding every rule change. As Warren Buffett said, “Risk comes from not knowing what you’re doing.” Let’s unravel SEBI’s latest framework for short selling, which is a powerful insight for traders like Arjun.

Short selling is a key strategy in global markets, enabling investors to profit from falling stock prices. SEBI’s latest circular (SEBI/HO/MRD/MRD-PoD-3/P/CIR/2024/1), issued on January 5, 2024, introduces updated guidelines to ensure fairness and transparency in short-selling practices.

What is Short Selling?

Short selling refers to selling a stock that the investor does not own at the time of the trade. The seller borrows the shares, sells them in the market, and later buys them back at a potentially lower price to return them to the lender, thereby profiting from the price difference.

Key Features of SEBI’s Short Selling Framework-

• Eligibility

• • Both retail and institutional investors can participate in short selling.
  • Naked short selling (selling without borrowing the stock) is not permitted.
  • Investors must honor delivery obligations during settlement.
    

• Trading Rules for Institutional Investors

• • Institutional investors are not allowed intra-day squaring off; they must settle obligations on a gross basis at the custodian level.
  • Retail investors, however, can square off positions intra-day.
    

• Securities Eligible for Short Selling

• • Only stocks traded in the F&O segment are eligible.
  • SEBI will periodically review and update the list of eligible stocks.
    

• Mandatory Disclosures

• • Institutional investors must disclose upfront if a trade is a short sale.
  • Retail investors can disclose short-selling positions by the end of trading hours on the same day.
    

• Stock Exchanges & Broker Responsibilities

• • Stock exchanges must implement deterrent provisions to ensure timely delivery of securities.
  • Brokers must collect and report scrip-wise short-sell data to the exchanges daily. The exchanges will then publish this data weekly for transparency.
    

• Securities Lending and Borrowing (SLB) Mechanism

• • To facilitate short selling, a Securities Lending and Borrowing (SLB) scheme is in place, allowing traders to borrow securities for short selling.
  • The SLB system ensures that investors who lend their shares earn an additional return while maintaining market liquidity.
    

• Segments Where Short Selling is Allowed

• • Short selling is permitted in:
    – Equity Cash Segment – Only in stocks eligible for the Securities Lending and Borrowing (SLB) mechanism.
    – Equity Derivatives (F&O) Segment – Stocks that are part of the Futures & Options (F&O) segment are eligible for short selling.
    

• Segments Where These New Rules Apply/Change

• • Institutional Investors in the Equity Cash Segment – The updated rules now enforce gross settlement at the custodian level, preventing intra-day squaring off.
  • Disclosure Requirements for Retail Investors – While retail investors previously had relaxed reporting norms, they now must disclose their short positions by the end of the trading day.

Key Changes in SEBI’s New Short Selling Rules

Aspect	Previous Rule	New Rule
Who Can Short Sell?	Retail & Institutional Investors	No change—both groups can short sell.
Naked Short Selling	Strictly prohibited	No change—naked short selling remains banned.
Institutional Trading	Institutions could square off positions intra-day	Institutions must settle obligations on a gross basis at the custodian level. No intra-day square-off.
Disclosure Rules	Institutional investors had to disclose upfront; retail investors had no strict reporting requirement.	Institutional investors still disclose upfront; retail investors must disclose short positions by end of the trading day.
Short Sell Data Reporting	Data was collected but not always made public frequently	Stock exchanges must publish short sell data weekly for transparency.

Real-World Scenarios: Impact of New Rules

Scenario 1: Institutional Investor – Mutual Fund Short Selling in Cash Market

✅ Before the new rule: The fund could square off its position on the same day without delivering shares.
❌ After the new rule: The fund must hold and deliver the shares on settlement day—no intra-day square-off is allowed for institutional investors.

Scenario 2: Retail Investor – Short Selling Disclosure Requirements

✅ Before the new rule: Retail investors could short-sell stocks without mandatory disclosure at the time of order placement. They had no strict end-of-day reporting requirements.
❌ After the new rule: Retail investors must disclose their short positions by the end of the trading day, increasing market transparency.

Scenario 3: Retail Investor – Failure to Deliver Securities

✅ Before the new rule: If a retail investor failed to deliver short-sold shares by settlement, they might have faced penalties, but there were no uniform deterrent provisions.
❌ After the new rule: Exchanges now have strict deterrent provisions against brokers for failure to deliver, ensuring a more disciplined market.

Additional Complex Scenarios for Retail Investors

1. Partially Covered Short Sell
   Example: A trader short-sells 1,000 shares of XYZ but owns only 600 shares. The uncovered 400 shares must be disclosed by the end of the trading day.
2. Short Selling a Stock That Is Suddenly Delisted from F&O
   Example: If a trader short-sells XYZ and it gets removed from the F&O list, the position remains valid and must still be disclosed per SEBI rules.
3. Short Selling During High Volatility (Circuit Limits Hit)
   Example: A trader short-sells XYZ at ₹7,500, expecting a drop, but the stock hits an upper circuit and trading halts. Since squaring off is not feasible, the position must still be disclosed.
4. Selling Already Held Shares vs. Short Selling
   Example: If an investor sells 500 shares of XYZ already in their demat account, no disclosure is needed. However, if they sell 800 shares (300 more than they own), the extra 300 must be disclosed as a short sale.
5. Short Selling Ahead of a Dividend Payout
   Example: A trader short-sells XYZ just before a ₹20 per share dividend announcement. They must disclose the short sale, and if they hold the position until settlement, they must compensate the lender for the dividend.

Importance of SEBI’s Updated Rules

The revised framework enhances market transparency, protects investor interests, and ensures efficient price discovery. By balancing participation with compliance, SEBI aims to create a more disciplined and efficient trading environment.

Final Thoughts

The revised SEBI framework offers clarity, transparency, and fairness in short selling. By enforcing stricter disclosures and settlement rules, SEBI not only protects market integrity but also empowers investors with insights to make informed decisions. For traders like Arjun—and for you—understanding these changes is key to mastering market moves.

Disclaimer: Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing. This content is purely for entertainment and engagement purposes only. Paytm Money Ltd SEBI Reg No. Broking – INZ000240532, Depository Participant – IN – DP – 416 – 2019, Depository Participant Number: CDSL – 12088800, NSE (90165), BSE (6707), Regd Office: 136, 1st Floor, Devika Tower, Nehru Place, Delhi – 110019. For more details, please visit https://www.paytmmoney.com